The Exit Objection to World Government Answered
The idea of world government has at its core the premise of opening up global mobility and abolishing borders. Yet in an interesting twist, some of its sceptics have accused it of restricting the so-called ‘exit option’, or the ability to flee from a regime that one is opposed to or is dysfunctional. They argue that while the world is divided into many states, one can flee to a different regime if conditions become unfavourable; yet should the world be brought under one government, one no longer has the option to escape to safety if the sole government turned against them. While much of this objection rests on the presumption of a tyrannical world government, which I have challenged in No. 12, here I shall discuss the exit option in a more general sense beyond political displacement.
Mobility is central to the fulfilment of all other liberties (No. 30), and conversely, the denial of other freedoms hinges on the inability to exit. In the present world, the principal reason why tyranny and oppression continue to prevail in many areas is because people lack a straightforward option to escape. Similarly, people are also trapped in areas of poverty, conflict, or disasters because of political and practical constraints on their ability to move. If given a choice, many people across the world will gladly avail of the exit option—yet alas, in a world divided by national boundaries, the lack thereof has had an uncountable cost in suffering and missed opportunities.
World government, by enabling world mobility, will provide many people with the ability to escape the unfavourable conditions that nationalism traps them in. Far from trampling upon exit rights, it will be the greatest enabler of the option to leave. True exit rights come with free mobility, which requires opening up the world to mass migration—something that no nationalist has the appetite for. The ability to freely migrate away from one’s present circumstances will be a game-changer for the way the world is run. People will vote with their feet and the entire world will be made to compete to provide the best living conditions to attract people. This is far from many national regimes which trap people in tyranny with no escape. Sceptics of world government fret about a loss of exit rights, but do the people suffering now really have an exit option?
One may say that in the national system, the asylum system exists for precisely this purpose. However, the purported ‘exit right’ of asylum applies only to a very limited scope—to people fleeing political persecution, as defined in Article 14 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. But is political persecution the only circumstance under which people should have an option? The asylum regime does not account for natural disasters, climate change, economic hardship, poverty, and other factors that could lead to displacement, and there is no recognition of a right to exit in these circumstances. We need exit rights not only for a few thousand political dissidents, but for the millions trapped in suffering by national boundaries.
Asylum was only ever a privilege available to those who are accepted by other countries; it is not a systematic right of exit. Moreover what little of the right to asylum was available has been steadily eroded by nations’ securitization of borders and movements. Apart from a very few high-profile dissidents who are readily taken in by other nations, that too only when it aligns with their geopolitical interests, most refugees have hardly any safe and legal pathways to asylum. The practical limitations on mobility and travel across borders that nationalism imposes make the exit option inaccessible for most people. And those that make it through face an increasingly precarious and restricted existence—being granted only temporary status, limited rights and pathways to integration, and often kicked out as soon as the immediate danger passes. Against this backdrop, it is difficult to see what rights a world government could possibly be restricting.
Hence it is inaccurate to say that world government will infringe upon exit rights—far from that, it will actively enable the exit option for the world’s population. Yet additionally, it will also make the world a safer and more just place by ending the ‘exit option’ for criminals and lawbreakers who can easily use it to evade justice now. Even as the exit option means little to those who need it most under nationalism, it provides impunity to those who can hide from the law by simply fleeing across a national border, with enforcement, extradition, and trial all remote possibilities. When humanity is united under one government, no one shall be beyond the reach of justice.
The exit objection also does not stand when compared to the global threats posed by nationalism itself, which endanger the entire human species. Where is one to exit from a world war, a nuclear winter, or global warming? Humanity cannot hope to hide from these threats by jumping from one nation to another; rather we must turn the page on nationalism and make the world safe for everyone. Even as nationalism aims only to maintain exclusive cocoons of safety and prosperity, world government holds promise for a future where no one is compelled to exit at all but everyone has the ability to do so, because everywhere is good enough.
Ultimately the exit option is anyways an irrelevant consideration: there is only one planet Earth where humans live, and from which we cannot escape yet both under nationalism and world government. If people want to flee from the world there is nothing one can do (except advance the necessary technology), regardless of whatever type of regime governs the world. But at least we can end the practice of imprisoning ourselves in smaller patches of the planet, by erasing national boundaries and opening up the cages which at present confine so many people to suffering and lost opportunities.



